Mitchel Mayhem reviews

Mitchel Mayhem has 20 reviews. See his full profile

I have to admit I was hesitant to come back to Mitchel given that he ghosted me last year after paying $40 for a custom. He was a new member of this site at the time and probably overwhelmed with new customers. I recently hit him up like nothing happened and ordered a new custom. Slightly higher price, but it reflected more typical rates that other guys here charge. He did the video this time and I have to admit: it was amazing. One of the best videos I’ve received from anyone here and for a great price. He’s got a naturally cocky and dominant swagger that so many other guys don’t have here. Mitchel got the script right the first time. 🗣️ I loved the video so much that I deleted both of my one star reviews of the past. My only wish is that he’d credit that $40 towards a new custom to make up for last year’s drama.

Pacificjello [2860] on 9 Mar 2026

MM totally embodies the musclegod persona. His cockiness and verbal dominance combined with those massive perfect muscles are almost too much to handle. A pleasure to deal with too. 10/10

AlwaysMirin [5550] on 28 Feb 2026

I got the best gift for Valentine's Day this year, which is a live show with Mitchel!!

Although on such short notice, Mitchel happened to be free and agreed to do a show before heading out for his day! He just finished the gym before the show, hence his physique was totally pumped and solid.

He is such an easy going guy, so any negative review about him must be fake!

E474 [14770] on 15 Feb 2026

Super rude guy, not recommended at all.

Qeturi.33 [1540] on 12 Feb 2026

Mitchel Mayhem replied...
Q- hi Mitchel- ?? Q- Can't you say fucking hi?! I came to you from the bestflex for a show Mitchel- Next time introduce yourself Who is the rude person in this conversation? Then has the audacity to post a review lmao

Recently received a phenomenal custom from Mitchel! Was so easy to arrange, lovely guy to chat to, and he recorded and delivered it in record time. The video was incredible-he followed all the details I requested and added in some amazing improvisation. His cockiness is unmatched and he is a true handsome, cocky muscle god (and looks amazing with the beard 😉). Can’t wait to get another video again soon!

mb707 [900] on 7 Feb 2026

Been absolutely killing it with customs! Hot body, even bigger muscles cocky and dom! He is everything i could dream of.

chompsticks.15 [2626] on 27 Jan 2026

I just had a show with this muscular god.

I wanted a virile, very muscular, and ripped man, and I got exactly what I was looking for.

What a man! He's dominant and knows exactly how to turn up the heat. The perfect alpha male. Don't hesitate any longer. You'll love watching him show off his muscles for you.

davparis [1247] on 11 Jan 2026

I reached out to Mitchel Mayhem for a live show, and that was the best decision!! He was nice and easy going when we tried to coordinate the best time for the show. Prior to the call, he also ensure what I would like to see during the show.

His physique was magnificent!! Not only was he a true muscle god (which he knows), he also knows how to showcasing such physique!! Really enjoy the flexing and show off from him during the show!

Definitely a 5-star no doubt!!

E474 [14770] on 10 Jan 2026

3rd show! He is amazing! I love having shows with him. He loves the attention, loves showing off and the energy is unmatched! Can't wait for more!

gofg [1716] on 4 Jan 2026

This guy is amazing. Been buying from him for a while now and have never been disappointed. He is probably the cockiest guy on the site and his muscles are absolutely mind blowing. Handsome face and fun personality to boot. I’m a huge fan.

AlwaysMirin [5550] on 22 Dec 2025

He’s the best. Easy to talk to and looks absolutely massive and jacked. 10/10 will ask for more

mgiad [270] on 16 Nov 2025

Just had my second show with him. Amazing! He looks even hotter right now. He’s clearly been away working hard on himself and it’s paid off. Loved my time with him even more this time.

gofg [1716] on 14 Nov 2025

I paid for a Video and this guy never sent it then I called him out about it on Telegram and he deleted me so its obvious he is stealing money from fans he has other reviews indicating so.

musclelvr [1361] on 14 Oct 2025

Mitchel Mayhem replied...
Seems like you already wrote a review that I sent you a video…and I have never blocked a paying customer👍🏼

Paid him for 4 videos, only ever delivered 2 videos , after repeated promises over many months. Too bad really.

harlanny [34599] on 2 Sep 2025

Mitchell is a musclegod for the ages! Have you seen his rock hard, deep cut, well-conditioned muscles?? And he’s a gentleman to deal with.

AlwaysMirin [5550] on 31 May 2025

I purchased a 10 minute custom pec play video from Mitchel last night. His responses were very prompt and he was easy to work with. He managed to make and send my custom video in less than an hour while still doing everything I requested. Highly recommend 👍🏻👍🏻. I’ll be requesting more videos from him soon! 😁

jadster16 [2515] on 29 May 2025

tldr; avoid at all costs as Mitchel is a waste of time and unserious. There is no denying he has a great physique, but the wasted time and lack of follow through really soured my experience.

I contacted him on 04/12 to book a live flex show, but we did not connect for that show until 9 days later on the 04/21. I prefer guys to be cocky / verbal within sessions and expressed this a couple of times, but he declined and indicated it would be best to commission a custom video for that kind of verbal. We agreed that I would send a script for him to review and he would make a video within the next 24 hours. I messaged him a couple of times in the following days and he did not respond until 6 days later (04/27) saying, "Ill check it out now". Further silence until 05/08 when he said, "Hey bro I can make it today💪🏼"...needless to say I do not have the video and am no longer holding my breath.

Anyone considering this guy is better off with someone that will follow through, as this lack of courtesy usually indicates the typical "cut and run" scheme which is all too common in this community.

856chiboy [820] on 12 May 2025

Just had a cam show with Mitchell---wow! Not sure how anyone manages to be that cocky and charming at the same time, but there it is. I mean, damn! He was really prompt about the show after we got that set up. His aesthetics are next level. He is this totally engaging musclegod whose pecs left me totally mesmerized. I feel lucky that Mitchell is willing to share his amazing personality, looks and physique with us. He is somehow even cooler than he looks.

BranchKenyon [92] on 31 Mar 2025

My first custom video from Mitchell was excellent. He was friendly and responsive to my requests. The video was exactly what I hoped for. His physique is amazing!

ryannz8400 [2345] on 15 Mar 2025

Just had a show. F*CK! Hes so hot and knows how to make you happy!
Will have more!

gofg [1716] on 9 Mar 2025

Write a review

Please Log In or Register to write a review.